Free-Range Kids – Our Family’s 9-Year Experience
Updated November 2026 (see update at the end)
Free-Range Kids: What Happened When I Gave My Kids More Independence
While walking out of the library the other day, a book titled Free-Range Kids by Lenore Skenazy caught my eye, so I grabbed it. I didn’t know the author, and reading a book like this was a bit unusual for me, but it piqued my interest. Honestly, I’m glad I saw this book!
Like many moms, I’ve spent a good portion of my time worrying about my children. Letting them walk to the corner store by themselves, ride their bikes around the neighborhood, or head to the park without me seemed like something parents just didn’t do anymore. And I wasn’t any different.
How often do we hear about an Amber Alert or another terrible story involving a child? With news available around the clock, it’s enough to make parents panic, but reading this book made me question something. Are we raising our children to be safe, or are we raising them to be afraid of the world?
What Are the Facts About Child Abductions?
How can we not be in fear when we hear the details of those cases that make the media, knowing that many don’t? With the increased “around the clock” media, we now perpetually worry about child abduction, and so we have decided that the outside is not an okay place for our children. But is that really true? What are the facts?
While we often say missing children, it should be noted that missing children and abducted children can mean different things. Children can run away from home or get lost and become missing children. Child abduction is something different. Here, a child has actually been taken by someone and is also missing.
The FBI reported that 464,324 missing-child records were entered into its national database in 2017, but it’s important to understand that being reported missing doesn’t necessarily mean a child has been abducted.
There is also no requirement that a child be missing for a certain amount of time before being reported to law enforcement. Parents can report their child missing immediately.
This means some of those 464,324 reports could involve children who went to a neighbor’s house, their parents couldn’t find them, understandably panicked, and called the police. Others involve children who have run away, become lost, or are in dangerous situations.
The Department of Justice has also reported that an estimated 105 children were victims of stereotypical kidnappings in 2011. These were serious kidnappings involving strangers or slight acquaintances that met specific criteria established by researchers.
It’s important to note that the 105 figure comes from a different study and year than the FBI’s missing-child reports, so the two numbers aren’t directly comparable. However, they do help us understand why the number of reported missing children is not the same as the number of children kidnapped by strangers.
In fact, according to a Department of Justice study of missing children, the breakdown of children reported missing to authorities in 1999 looked like this:
- 45% Runaways or children who were forced or told to leave home
- 43% Missing due to misunderstandings or miscommunications about their whereabouts
- 8% Lost, injured, or otherwise involuntarily missing
- 7% Family abductions
- 2% Non-family abductions, including strangers and other people who weren’t family members
These percentages come from a study specifically about children under 18. They can add up to more than 100% because some children experienced more than one type of missing episode. The estimates also have varying degrees of uncertainty, particularly the non-family abduction figure.
While these numbers are from 1999, they help explain something important… children go missing for many different reasons, and the majority of those situations are not stranger kidnappings. However, when children do go missing, the media reports phrases like hundreds of thousands of missing children, and this causes the average American to wonder if there is an increase in child abductions.
Does that number actually mean kidnappings are increasing? The answer is… not necessarily!
The Department of Justice has reported that the rate of children reported missing to authorities fell approximately 52% between 1999 and 2013. In 1999, 6.5 out of every 1,000 children were reported missing, compared to 3.1 out of every 1,000 children in 2013. That’s a pretty significant decline!
The Department of Justice also found that the estimated number of stereotypical kidnappings was virtually the same in 2011 as it had been in 1997. And while we often think of small children being abducted, the most common victims in that particular kidnapping study were older children, ages 12–17.
Sadly, these facts show that crimes against children do exist, and as parents (or everyone, because it takes a village), we need to be aware of that. However, these facts also show that the number of children reported missing is nowhere near the same as the number of children abducted by strangers.
One crime against one child is one too many! These numbers are not meant to say that crimes against children do not happen, because they do. But they are meant to show that hundreds of thousands of missing-child reports do not mean hundreds of thousands of children are being kidnapped.
As parents, we absolutely need to protect our children, but I also think we need to understand the facts rather than make every decision based on fear.
Reading Free-Range Kids
Until very recently, I was almost too scared to let my children play outside in our front yard without me. The thought of allowing them to experience the kind of childhood I had was terrifying.
I grew up riding my bike everywhere, walking to the corner store for candy, and spending hours playing around the neighborhood with friends. We didn’t have cell phones, and our parents certainly didn’t know where we were every minute. We had rules, of course, but we also had a lot of freedom.
I have wonderful memories of that childhood, and somewhere in the back of my mind, I knew I wanted my kids to have some of those same experiences.
My goal is to raise children who can handle themselves, who don’t need me for every little thing, and who feel comfortable in the real world. But how could I expect them to develop those skills if I never gave them the opportunity?
That’s what made Free-Range Kids so interesting to me. The book challenges parents to consider how fear, media coverage, and changing expectations about childhood influence our decisions. It also makes the argument that children need opportunities to practice independence rather than having adults handle everything for them.
I recommend reading it, even if you aren’t sure you agree with the idea of free-range parenting. It certainly gave me a different perspective.
If you’re interested, you can find Free-Range Kids by Lenore Skenazy here.
Of Course, the Book Isn’t Without Controversy
Lenore Skenazy received a lot of criticism after allowing her nine-year-old son to ride the New York City subway by himself. Some people called her irresponsible and questioned her judgment as a parent. I can understand why the story made people uncomfortable. The idea of letting a nine-year-old navigate the subway alone would make plenty of parents nervous, myself included. but that doesn’t necessarily mean every child, family, or situation is the same.
One thing I felt the book could have discussed more was how much location matters. Living in a small rural town is very different from living in a busy city, and even neighborhoods within the same city can have very different traffic patterns and safety concerns.
A child’s age, maturity, experience, and surroundings all matter. I don’t think there’s one magical age when every child suddenly becomes ready to do everything independently. I also don’t think parents should feel pressured into giving their children more freedom than they’re prepared to handle.
The point I took away from the book wasn’t that we should throw caution out the window. It was that perhaps an entire generation of parents had started making some decisions based on fear rather than their children’s actual abilities. That was something I needed to think about.
What I Learned About Raising Independent Kids
- Free-Range children are children that can live life much like those of the 80s and earlier. They can ride their bikes around the neighborhoods and be able to experience some independence without constant parental supervision.
- I have learned that as a parent I need to realize dangers are present and real, however, I also learned that I need to do research and not get caught up in sensationalized media reporting.
- I now understand that my kids are capable of more than I thought and that they can be trusted to follow the rules my husband and I set.
- Children, like adults, learn through experiences and they need to be given a chance to live those experiences (within reason).
- I learned to talk to my kids about dangers without making them scared of the world around them.
- Most importantly, I have learned that having kids outdoors and unaccompanied doesn’t equate to being unsafe. This was a slow process and is still evolving.
Putting This New Way of Thinking Into Practice
My husband and I sat down with the kids, who are 7, 8, and 9, and explained the dangers… people driving too fast, people texting and driving, people acting weird or funny, and the like. They also know that rarely a child is taken and bad things do happen, we didn’t hide that point either.
We also went on to give a set of rules that had to be followed… staying together, crossing at the corners, NEVER going with someone they don’t know or that isn’t on the list of approved people, they are to always let us know where they are, and lastly… and this one might bring me some hate… but we let them know it is OK to talk to strangers.
Strangers aren’t all bad. I see little old ladies talking to kids in the stores only to have those kids ignore them or say they can’t talk to strangers, and if something is wrong with your child, they might be afraid to get help because they don’t want to get in trouble for talking to a stranger.
We instead explained that if they are in trouble, and we aren’t available, they should find a police officer/fireman, a parent, or even another kid to bring into the situation. Truth is most people want to help and telling your child strangers are bad is closing them off from humanity.
After this talk, we allowed them to go to the park 1 block away, by themselves but together. Then, we started allowing them to ride their bikes around a few blocks. Next, they were able to walk to the corner store, which is 2 blocks and across Main St.
Since then, they have been allowed to walk to and from piano practice which is 3 blocks (the piano teacher and I text each other about departure and arrival and the picture above is where they were coming from), the city park which is 7 blocks (for longer trips they carry my phone), and in general are able to play in the neighborhood with their friends without a helicopter parent. The kids have even started walking the neighbor’s dogs for extra income and they do this by themselves for several blocks.
Do I worry… yes!
I let them walk home from martial arts for the first time just this week, and I was worried because the location is in the heart of our town (we have about 6000 people in our town). My worry didn’t come from not trusting them and honestly, after learning the statistics very little of my worry came from what could happen to them… my worry came from what other people would say.
What a ridiculous thing to worry about… but parents today are very vocal with their judgment.
I have read about a case of parents in Maryland who had issues with people calling the police on them for doing exactly what I was… letting their kids “free-range” and I was worried this would happen to me. I think some of this worry comes from the fact that I also homeschool, something many people consider odd to begin with. Of course, statistically speaking, that would be an extreme, rare event too but it still worries me from time to time.
Last Thoughts
Growing up in the 80s, I can appreciate the concept of free-range parenting as it is how I and my entire generation was raised. I have so many fond memories of running around with friends and it is a sad thought that generations are missing out on that!
As parents, we’re always going to worry. It’s part of loving our children, and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with being cautious. But I also think there’s a difference between protecting children and preventing them from having experiences that help them grow. We live in an imperfect world, and I know there are dangers. That’s why we need to teach our children, get to know our neighbors, pay attention to what’s happening in our communities, and make thoughtful decisions about what our children are ready to handle.
Reading this book and doing some of my own research has helped me feel more comfortable giving my children a few important gifts: freedom, choice, experience, responsibility, and confidence.
Free-range parenting certainly isn’t for everyone, and every family needs to consider its own circumstances. But I do recommend reading Free-Range Kids, if only to see a different perspective.
BEM and Fam 🙂
Free-Range Kids: Nine Years Later, Would I Do It Again? (2026 Update)
I originally wrote this post back in 2017, after stumbling across Free-Range Kids by Lenore Skenazy at our local library. At the time, my kids were 7, 8, and 9, and I was struggling with the idea of giving them some of the independence I had enjoyed growing up.
I wanted my children to be able to ride their bikes around town, walk to the park, and enjoy being kids without having me watching their every move. But, like most parents, I worried. A lot! Reading that book made me reconsider some of those fears, and my husband and I decided to start giving the kids a little more freedom. We had rules, of course, and started small, but eventually they were riding their bikes to the city park, walking to piano lessons, and spending time around the neighborhood without us constantly supervising.
So, here we are, nine years later. My kids are older, and I thought it might be interesting to revisit this post and share how things have gone. Do I still believe in free-range parenting?
The short answer is… yes!
What Happened When We Gave Our Kids More Independence?
Over the years, my children have been able to enjoy quite a few of the freedoms I remember having as a child. They’ve ridden their bikes to the city park and pool, walked around town, spent time with their friends, and even used longboards their grandparents bought them to get to Jiu-Jitsu lessons during the warmer months.
What I found most interesting was that the more responsibility we gave them, the more seriously they seemed to take it. From the beginning, we made it clear that freedom came with rules. They needed to let us know where they were going, stay together when required, follow traffic rules, and never accept a ride without our permission. With almost no exceptions, they followed those rules.
I think part of that was because they understood why we had them. We weren’t simply telling them no because we were the parents. We explained the dangers, discussed what could happen, and gave them the opportunity to show us they could make good decisions.
One of my favorite examples happened when the kids were walking to a baseball game. The mother of one of my son’s teammates stopped and offered them a ride. They knew her, but they politely declined.
She tried to convince them to get in, and they continued to say no. Later, she called to tell me what had happened. She wanted me to know that the kids were polite, thanked her for the offer, but wouldn’t accept the ride without permission.
She then told me I’d done a good job!
In a world where parents can be pretty quick to criticize each other, it was nice to hear something positive. More importantly, I was so proud that the kids had followed a rule we established years earlier, even when someone they knew encouraged them to do otherwise. I will say that my son did question his older sister’s refusal, but he followed the rules all the same.
That doesn’t mean everything about free-range parenting has been easy, or that I haven’t questioned some of our decisions.
The Delphi Murders Made Me Question Everything
In 2017, the same year I originally wrote this post, two girls, Abigail Williams, 13, and Liberty German, 14, were murdered while walking on a trail near Delphi, Indiana. Delphi is less than an hour from our home, and it’s an even smaller community than ours. For reasons involving our local news coverage, we didn’t really hear much about the case until a couple of years later.
When I did, it was heartbreaking. These girls had simply gone for a walk, something I had been encouraging my own children to feel comfortable doing. It made me question whether I’d been wrong. Were children safe anywhere? Was I allowing my kids too much freedom? Should I have kept them closer to home?
My heart breaks for these families, and for every family that has experienced something terrible happening to their child. Statistics don’t make what happened any less tragic, and I certainly wouldn’t suggest otherwise… but I also realized that, as much as I wanted to, I couldn’t protect my children from every possible danger. Keeping them inside or constantly beside me wouldn’t prepare them for the world they were eventually going to have to navigate on their own.
That doesn’t mean ignoring danger. It means understanding it, preparing for it, and making decisions based on more than fear… and that brings me back to the statistics that originally caught my attention.
What Do the Latest Missing-Child Statistics Show?
When I originally wrote this article, I was surprised by how differently missing children and child abductions were reported and discussed. We hear about hundreds of thousands of missing children each year, and it’s easy to picture an enormous number of children being kidnapped by strangers. But those two things aren’t the same.
I decided to look at the most recent FBI statistics to see what had changed since 2017, and the numbers were interesting!
According to the FBI’s National Crime Information Center (NCIC):
- 2017: 464,324 missing-child records were entered for children under 18.
- 2025: 323,767 missing-child records were entered for children under 18.
That’s a decrease of 140,557 records, or approximately 30%, between 2017 and 2025. That’s a pretty significant difference!
Of course, these are records of children reported missing, not a count of children who were kidnapped or who remained missing. Reporting practices and other factors can affect the numbers, too.
The FBI also has a category called involuntary, which includes missing children whose disappearance may not have been voluntary, such as a suspected abduction or kidnapping.
In 2017, 5,271 children were entered into that category. In 2025, the number was 2,757 children.
That’s a decrease of approximately 48%.
Now, I want to be clear about something. These are cases classified by the circumstances of a disappearance. They are not all confirmed kidnappings, and they certainly aren’t all confirmed stranger abductions. We can’t assume from these figures alone that actual kidnappings decreased by 48%, but the numbers are interesting, especially when you consider how often we hear frightening stories about children going missing.
So, while we can clearly see a reduction in FBI missing-child records since 2017, I wouldn’t say the statistics prove every type of child abduction is declining. Still, I think they reinforce something I learned when I first picked up Free-Range Kids: we need to understand what the numbers actually mean before allowing them to influence every decision we make.
One crime against one child is one too many! I will always believe that, but I also don’t believe children should grow up thinking the world is full of people waiting to hurt them.
We need to be careful, we need to be informed, and we need to teach our children how to handle themselves.
You can read the FBI’s 2017 report, the 2025 report, and the Department of Justice’s kidnapping research if you’d like to look at the numbers yourself.
Helping Our Children Become Independent
After all these years, I still believe that one of the most important things we can do for our children is teach them how to live in the world, rather than trying to hide them from it.
This doesn’t mean giving children unlimited freedom or ignoring the dangers around them. It means preparing them for those dangers in a way they can understand. There are a few things I still believe are especially important.
- Talk to children about dangers in an age-appropriate way. We can’t prepare children for a world we never allow them to experience.
- Teach kids that it’s okay to trust their instincts, and then actually listen when they tell us something or someone makes them uncomfortable.
- Get away from the idea that every stranger is bad. Children should know that it’s okay to ask for help, while also understanding that talking to someone isn’t the same as going somewhere with them.
- Set clear rules, explain why those rules matter, and be consistent.
- Give children opportunities to make decisions and take responsibility, gradually increasing their freedom as they show they’re ready.
- Get to know your neighbors and help create communities where people look out for each other.
I also think we need to consider the individual child. Some children are ready for certain responsibilities earlier than others, and that is okay! Their age, maturity, experience, and the safety of their surroundings should all play a part.
A child walking down a quiet residential street is facing a different situation than one crossing a busy highway. There isn’t a single answer that works for every family. What matters is that we’re teaching our children the skills they’ll need rather than assuming those skills will magically appear when they turn eighteen.
Would I Recommend Free-Range Parenting Today?
Absolutely, although I think the term free-range parenting sometimes makes people imagine children running wild with no rules or supervision. That certainly wasn’t our experience! We had rules, we had expectations, and we took the responsibility of preparing our children seriously.
I worried about them then, and I still worry about them now. I don’t think that will ever change, no matter how old they get! However, I’m glad we allowed them to experience some independence. I’m glad they had opportunities to ride their bikes around town, spend time with friends, and learn that they could handle things without needing Mom or Dad beside them every minute.
I also think that independence helped them become more confident and responsible, although, of course, there are many things that contribute to how children grow up. Looking back, I wouldn’t change our overall approach.
A Little More About Free-Range Kids
Since I first read Free-Range Kids, Lenore Skenazy has published an expanded second edition titled Free-Range Kids: How Parents and Teachers Can Let Go and Let Grow.
I came across the newer edition, and I was especially interested in the additional material for teachers. As someone who has spent years homeschooling and teaching children online, I think the connection between teaching responsibility and allowing children to become independent is worth exploring.
Grab the Newest Edition of Free-Range Kids on Amazon
My Final Thoughts
When I picked up that book at the library nine years ago, I had no idea how much it would change some of my parenting decisions. I certainly didn’t expect to be writing about it all these years later!
I’ve always wanted my children to grow up feeling capable, confident, and comfortable in the world around them. While I can’t say that free-range parenting is responsible for all of that, I do think giving them opportunities to be independent has helped.
I’d love to hear what you think! Did you grow up with the same kinds of freedoms I did? Do you allow your children to walk around the neighborhood or spend time at the park without you? Or does the idea make you a little nervous?
Leave a comment below or find me on Instagram or Facebook at @bemandfam. I’d love to hear about your experiences!
BEM and Fam 🙂
👇 Save This for Later
Want to come back to this? Pin it so you can find it again when you’re ready!




